January Re-Read
I read The Lord of the Rings last January, and I'm planning on reading it again this January. This time I plan to start with The Hobbit and finish with The Silmarillion.
How many times have you read this series? Does this forum make you want to re-read it?
Originally Posted by Fynn
I read it once. I'm okay with that for now
I've read The Hobbit several times, the entire LotR series twice through, and have reread The Fellowship of the Rings several times over, but definitely not in the last eight or so years. I picked up The Hobbit in December of 2012, but became distracted and did not finish it.
Probably won't be joining this because I have a bazillion books I'm trying to get through and would rather focus on new material right now.
I guess I just have a hard time setting aside time for reading, because I just finished reading the trilogy about a week ago; that's with having started Fellowship around March, 2013, and reading them back-to-back with no other books in between.
It's alright, though. I feel like it gave me time to really absorb Tolkien's writing. Without a doubt he's one of my favorite authors now.
Why are you reading the Silmarillion last? It takes place before the other two
I think I've read LotR and the Hobbit three times, and the Silmarillion twice. Children of Hurin three times.
I was just sort of taking The Silmarillion on wherever. Do you think I should read it first?
It's an easier book to read than LotR, for whatever that's worth. The difficulty is remembering all of the different characters with similar names.
Read them all about 3 times now, I think. Maybe more.
I agree, it makes so much of the books easier to understand if you read it first. It's the history. Read it or you will not be part of the LOTR master race.Why are you reading the Silmarillion last? It takes place before the other two
I'm not sure how I'd feel about January Jones being in the movies.
This would be ideal, actually. I usually re-read this and A Christmas Carol every December, but Good Omens and a slew of other books have been distracting me.
I think a discussion-fuelled re-read thread would be lovely.
Alright. I am gonna do this.
It isn't a reread for me though. I could never get through any of them but the Hobbit.
<PaperStar> live fast, die young, bad plefs do it well
I've just read The Hobbit earlier this year.
I've read The Hobbit maybe... once? I did enjoy it though and just haven't gotten around to a re-read.
I never did read LotR and honestly I'm not really interested in doing so. If I ever do it I think it will probably be because I "should" do so as a speculative fiction writer. You know, a history lesson of sorts.
I mentioned it above, but I just finished a full read-through as an adult and found a lot of satisfaction in it. I had tried reading it as a teen and just didn't have the patience for it. Tolkien's prose is magnificent, so I agree it's probably valuable for that alone (not to say that you MUST read it as a writer, it's up to you). I liked it a lot more by slowly digesting it rather than just trying to blow through it, but ymmv.
I never make the time to read anymore. I have a book - which ends a series I've read for years - sitting next to me and I've not read a bit of it. I've had it there for about a year. Someday I'll get to it. I just never find the time because there are so many things I want to do and it's always just a couple of notches down the list in priority. Perhaps I'll re-read LotR someday, but having read it about 7-10 times I'm in no rush.
Bow before the mighty Javoo!
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
