I wouldn't get the roxio if you're going to stream. The roxio thing only works with their own software, and that software is very poor if you want to stream. It can capture video to your HDD in high quality, but the quality it delivers on twitch is mediocre at best, awful at worst. I have an elgato HD60, but that one doesn't work with PS3 because PS3 forces encryption on HDMI, and the HD60 only has HDMI input. The previous elgato box does however support PS3 if you buy component RGB cables to use with it. Out of these two, I found the elgato software to be vastly superior.