"We all know Final Fantasy XIII sucked, Lightning was terrible."
Mhm - except for the other millions of fans who disagree with you.
So yes, fans are great.
NOTE: I do still find some of their comments funny.
This is what I was referring to. I got the impression you were siding with the "millions of fans who disagree". Not that it matters. But just to answer your question
Yes, I disagree with them. However I do not know how that makes you think I think "it has a bad story but good gameplay so I still love it". As far as it goes Final Fantasy XIII for me has good story and gameplay while having its flaws.