Pluralization

[Madame Adequate]

I would like to know what you think the plural of "Phoenix Down" is.

[Jinx]

Phoenixes Downses

(My answer is 'Phoenix Downs' but 'Phoenixes Down' is probably the more grammatically correct pluralization.)

[Electroshock Therapy]

I voted Phoenix Downs just because that's how I say it.
I agree with Jinx that Phoenixes Down seems the most correct.
However, saying Phoenixes Downs is more fun.

[Pumpkin]

you know

[Electroshock Therapy]

I just realized I should have voted for "Other"

Phoenixi Downi if gender is masculine
Phoenixae Downae if feminine
Phoenixa Downa if neuter.

[VeloZer0]

pff.. only noobs ever need to stock more than one any ways.

[qwertysaur]

The plural of down is downs for the particular meaning of the word. So Phoenix downs.

[Old Manus]

Sounds like an affliction for phoenixes with chromosome issues. "Oh, ignore that one. It has phoenix downs."

[Bubba]

Phoenix down to chinatown.

[Shauna]

I probably say Phoenix Downs, but thinking about it, I believe the correct term would be Phoenix Down. Feather down would be the plural in itself, right?

EDIT: Nope, a quick check shows that the plural of down is downs so there we go.

[Del Murder]

Phoenixen Down

[Jinx]

I'm following the rule of things like 'culs-de-sac' and 'sisters-in-law'.

[Scotty_ffgamer]

I call 'em Pheeney Ds.

[metagloria]

Phoenix up.

[Randy]

Lol well this topic made me realize what they actually are. For some reason I never noticed that it meant "down" in the sense of feathers. Duhhhhhh.
So I guess the second is technically correct. Although I guess the entire thing is slightly grammatically incorrect in that they say you have 1 phoenix down. That is wrong from the start. That's surely the equivalent of saying "I have 1 hairs".