the horrifying secret of EoFF

[Galuf]

I discovered something horrible and horrifying. Guaranteed nightmare fuel.
I was searching through the smileys and then i found
well
this....

this is true terror. And really scary. Beware... Beware...

[Mirage]

Welcome to last decade!

[Chris]

Before her time.

[Ayen]

is a pretty good counter to the Gotta keep that asshole in line, after all.

[Formalhaut]

[Chris]

Sarah, we, Band of Brothers, are attacking you. Defend yourself.

[I Took the Red Pill]

Grover smilie is only appropriate in very specific situations. One of these days you'll be typing out a post and just "know" that a grover belongs there. I'm pretty sure ShlupQuack almost deleted grover a few years back, so consider yourself lucky that he's still around.

[Galuf]

I want the shlup quack

[theundeadhero]

Grover was my favorite Sesame Street character. I fought for you against the Shlupduck before and I'll keep fighting for you forever

[Ayen]

no, the actual horrifying thing about eoff is that we're all lizard people

Shh! That's classified information!

[Mirage]

oh wow is that actually sarah?

[Aulayna]

I thought this was finally the revelation that Bob's name is in fact actually Bob!

[theundeadhero]

No, Bob is the cat. His name is BoB.

[Zeldy]

Wasn't there a Grover that was dancing?

[Araciel]

I don't... what?