Rate your Games 2015

[Sephiroth]

I only rate games that I have at least played for an hour otherwise my impression is probably gonna be useless.

Tales of Xillia 1: 7-8/10
Tales of Graces f: 8/10
Majin and the Forsaken Kingdom: 5/10
Alice: Madness Returns: 8/10
Remember Me 7/10
Silent Hill 1: 7-8/10
Bayonetta 2: 10/10
Shadow Hearts: Covenant: 6-7/10
Atelier Shallie The Alchemist of Dusk Sea: 7/10
Silent Hill Homecoming: 6/10
Batman Arkham Asylum: 7/10
Fatal Frame V: Project Zero Maiden of Black Water: 8/10
Atelier Sophie The Alchemist of the Wonder Book: 7-8/10
The Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess: 8-9/10
Super Smash Bros. Wii U: 8/10

[Aulayna]

FFXIV Heavensward 6.5/10
FF Type-0 8/10
Fallout 4 9/10
AC Syndicate 8/10
Overwatch 10/10

[Wolf Kanno]

I'm sticking to games I've finished and not replays.

Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds - 9/10
Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes - 7/10
Bioshock - 6/10
Zone of the Enders - 6/10
Portal - 9/10
Metal Gear Solid: The Phantom Pain - 10/10 GotY

[Formalhaut]

Right, okay, here we go. Dragon Age: Inquisition is marked harshly here, primarily for the shocking state of the game's sidequests. Borderlands 2 would probably be marked a few decimals lower, but I played with Mr. Carny which resulted in some fun evenings.

Persona 3: Portable - 9.0/10
Persona 4: Golden - 9.3/10 (My GOtY)
Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth - 8.5/10
Borderlands 2 - 9.0/10
Dragon Age 2 - 8.4/10
Dragon Age: Inquisition - 7.5/10
Pokemon X/Y - 8.1/10
Miles Edgeworth: Investigations 2 - 8.0/10
Final Fantasy Tactics: War of the Lions - 8.4/10

My 2016 list is pretty heaving, to be honest, with several games releasing for the new PS4.

EDIT:

There's actually a few things I forgot that I've played this year, too:


999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors - 8.0/10
Professor Layton vs Phoenix Wright - 9.1/10
Phoenix Wright: Dual Destinies - 8.8/10

[Aulayna]

I really want to try P4 as Risette's character really interests me. I watched the Golden Animation but it skips over quite a lot of stuff it seems.

[Formalhaut]

I really want to try P4 as Risette's character really interests me. I watched the Golden Animation but it skips over quite a lot of stuff it seems.

I've never watched any of the anime series, but The Golden Animation apparently only covers the new additions introduced in P4: Golden. There's the original animation series which covers the events of the game proper.

But no, play the game. It's really good! The animation apparently makes the P4MC's character less friendly in certain places, so play the game.

[Pumpkin]

New games I've played/am playing. Not counting replayed games, also only from March forward because I don't remember which were new before then!

Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer - 5.5/10
AquaPazza - 7.5/10
Arcana Heart 3 Love Max!!!!! - 7.5/10
Atelier Ayesha - 6/10
Atelier Rorona 7/10
Atelier Shallie 7/10
BlazBlue Chronophantasma - 2/10
Cherry Tree High Comedy Club - 4/10
Clannad - 7.5/10
Conception II - 7/10
Dead or Alive 5 Last Round - 7/10
Doodle God - 6/10
Dragon Quest IV - 4/10
Fallout: New Vegas - 8/10
Fallout 4 - 7/10
Fantasy Life - 6.5/10
fault milestone one - 7/10
Final Fantasy Type-0 - 6/10
Futurama - 2/10
Hyperdevotion Noire - 4/10
Hyperdimension Neptunia mk II - 6/10
Hyperdimension Neptuinia PP - 6/10
Illusion of Gaia - 5/10
King of Fighters XIII - 4/10
Kitty Powers' Matchmaker - 6.5/10
Legend of Legacy - 6/10
Long Live the Queen - 5.5/10
Lord of Magna: Maiden Heaven - 7.5/10
Mass Effect 2 - 7.5/10
Mortal Kombat Komplete Edition - 6/10
New Little King's Story - 6/10
Omega Quintet - 7/10
Persona 3 Portable - 5/10
Persona 4 Golden - 6.5/10
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - 5/10
Scribblenauts Unlimited - 8/10
Style Savvy Trendsetters - 8/10
Super Mario Bros. 3 - 4/10
Tales of Graces f - 7/10
Tales of Hearts R - 9.5/10
Tales of Zestiria - 8/10
Tears to Tiara II - 7.5/10
Test Drive Unlimited 2 - 6/10
The Guided Fate Paradox - 6/10
Tokyo School Life - 8/10
Umineko ep. 1-4 - 5/10
Virtua Fighter 4 - 3/10
Ys: Memories of Celceta - 8/10

It's funny how hindsight will change the opinion on some of these games from what I thought previously

[Sephex]

I'm going to note if I haven't beaten the game yet, but know that I put a lot of time in the games that I haven't beaten yet. I am enjoying said games, so the rating will probably go up upon completion. Also, I hate these type of game scores, so yeah.

Persona 4 Golden - 7.5/10 [[not yet beaten over 30 hours put in]]
Super Mario Maker - 8/10
Metal Gear Solid 5 - 8.5/10
Illusion of Gaia - 7.5/10
Majora's Mask DS - 9/10
Batman Arkham Knight - 7/10 [[not yet beaten over 20 hours put in]]
Fallout 4 - 7/10 [[not beaten yet about 13 hours in, but enjoying it more as I play...won't beat New Vegas for me though]]
Undertale - 10/10 (GOTY)

Not only does Undertale cater to my craving of EarthBound-like stuff, but I was pleasantly surprised by how well written the game is, and how it is a massive homage to jRPGs in general while still strongly retaining its own identity. Plus, the game has caused me to have a very strong emotional reaction to it, which is very unusual for a person like myself.

[Formalhaut]

Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer - 5.5/10
Atelier Ayesha - 6/10
BlazBlue Chronophantasma - 2/10
Cherry Tree High Comedy Club - 4/10
Doodle God - 6/10
Dragon Quest IV - 4/10
Fantasy Life - 6.5/10
Final Fantasy Type-0 - 6/10
Futurama - 2/10
Hyperdevotion Noire - 4/10
Hyperdimension Neptunia mk II - 6/10
Hyperdimension Neptuinia PP - 6/10
Illusion of Gaia - 5/10
King of Fighters XIII - 4/10
Kitty Powers' Matchmaker - 6.5/10
Legend of Legacy - 6/10
Long Live the Queen - 5.5/10
Mortal Kombat Komplete Edition - 6/10
New Little King's Story - 6/10
Persona 3 Portable - 5/10
Persona 4 Golden - 6.5/10
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - 5/10
Test Drive Unlimited 2 - 6/10
The Guided Fate Paradox - 6/10
Umineko ep. 1-4 - 5/10
Virtua Fighter 4 - 3/10

Wow, so many games that are underneath a 7/10. Having said that, I've not played nearly as many games as you have this year. Your Persona scores were lower than mine; I'd like to know why, because me and Mr. Carny really enjoyed them!

[Pumpkin]

Yeah a 5/10 is an average for me. Meaning I enjoyed it but it wasn't like AMAZING~ whereas a 7/10 means it's a very solid game that I will most likely replay and I really enjoyed. Above that means it was pretty great

I enjoyed the Persona games when I was playing them, I really did. But now, looking back on it... they just don't get me excited. I'm not sure if I will ever replay them. I think I will 4 but 3 just brings up more bad memories than good. So much dungeon and grinding and terrible pacing. While it certainly had some good spots, good characters and story for example, I'm not sure if it's worth going through the negatives again.

It was worth it to go through them once (obviously, or I would have rated them under a 5) and I did enjoy them, don't get me wrong. They are good, quality games. I am happy I played them. But they don't get me excited to play them again, if you get my meaning?

[Mr. Carnelian]

Persona 3: Portable - 7/10
Persona 4: Golden - 8/10
Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth - 7/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 8/10
Tomb Raider Underworld - 8/10
Borderlands 2 - 8/10
Dragon Age 2 - 9/10
Dragon Age: Inquisition - 8.5/10
Professor Layton vs Phoenix Wright - 8/10

I think that's everything!

[Spuuky]

Wow, so many games that are underneath a 7/10.

Half of all games should be 5/10 or below. Something like 90% of games should be between a 3 and an 8.

[Psychotic]

Wow, so many games that are underneath a 7/10.

Half of all games should be 5/10 or below. Something like 90% of games should be between a 3 and an 8.

Not at all.

[Formalhaut]

Yeah a 5/10 is an average for me. Meaning I enjoyed it but it wasn't like AMAZING~ whereas a 7/10 means it's a very solid game that I will most likely replay and I really enjoyed. Above that means it was pretty great

I think this is where we've differed in understanding about the scale. I tend to read reviews rather often, and basically any game below a 7 is varying degrees of 'rubbish'. A 7 itself is only a passing mark as far as games are concerned, and I guess I get sucked into that line of thinking.

When I rate games, giving it a 7.5 is my way of saying "I enjoyed it, but there were undeniable flaws that cannot be overlooked", so a 7 is sort of like 'satisfactory'.

I don't really rate anything lower than a 7 unless I really didn't like it. Thankfully, I tend to play games I think I'll like, so I rarely hand out a 6.

I enjoyed the Persona games when I was playing them, I really did. But now, looking back on it... they just don't get me excited. I'm not sure if I will ever replay them. I think I will 4 but 3 just brings up more bad memories than good. So much dungeon and grinding and terrible pacing. While it certainly had some good spots, good characters and story for example, I'm not sure if it's worth going through the negatives again.

It was worth it to go through them once (obviously, or I would have rated them under a 5) and I did enjoy them, don't get me wrong. They are good, quality games. I am happy I played them. But they don't get me excited to play them again, if you get my meaning?

I think the only major flaw with Persona 3 is the pacing. There are admittedly periods where not much really happens. The social links are supposed to fill the gaps when the main story goes quiet, but it doesn't always work. Persona 4 had better pacing, except for a period in the summer when things do go a tad quiet. But I prefer Persona 4 to Persona 3, hence the slightly higher rating. I still happened to really enjoy Persona 3.

[Pumpkin]

I used to do the 7-10 (or 5 to 10, I guess, with 5 being terrible, 7 average, and 10 great) grading scale as well but sharky pointed out that there are numbers before that and a 5 would be in the middle/average. A game above 5=above average and a game below 5=below average. It made sense to me what he was saying so I have moved away from the whole under 7=bad thing that I used to do

But yeah if you see my video game diary, I like most games I play as well! I am rarely disappointed and I rarely give up on a game or just end up not liking it

edit:
not to say the below 7=bad scale is wrong, if that's what you prefer, I just decided the other way made more sense to me personally