I actually have both a PS3 and an XBOX 360. I brought the PS3. Mr. Carny contributed the XBOX 360. I'd give the edge overall to the PS3. I prefer the PS3 controller marginally over the 360 controller, although both were pretty good. In terms of games, my library has a majority of PS3 games, although Mass Effect, two of the Dragon Age games and Borderlands 2 are my favourites from the XBOX collection. On the other hand, there was Uncharted, Final Fantasy and Tales of Xillia, among others. Some of them probably aren't exclusives, but the entire concept of exclusivity is just strange.

The interface on both needs works. the PS3's 'single row' menu is strange, to say the least. I'm used to it, but it isn't great. The XBOX interface is also odd. On the surface, it looks more lively and interesting, but half of the options are just advertising or asking you to take Gold. I'm not an on-line fan, so that's pretty useless to me.

Honestly, the PS4 main menu is also pretty rubbish as well. Both consoles aren't excelling at making clear menus that you can customise to your liking.