Overall I tend to agree that P4 was stronger in most ways (except for dungeon design). Even though I enjoyed P3P when I first played it P4G was what really blew me away. That being said I do think there is some great music in P5, the art design is pretty spectacular etc. But I would agree that in terms of the story and characters P4 is probably the best. And it definitely had a lot more warmth than P5. Maybe I'm just not the right kind of person to enjoy the darker aspects of most SMT games. I've played a lot of them, and enjoy some elements, but nothing has grabbed me as much as P4.