EoFF Mafia Dissidia

[Formalhaut]

dang I kinda wanna also do it for that sweet alliteration. I'm all about alliteration

It's as good a reason as any other on Day One

[qwertysaur]

Wow a lot happened while I was asleep. Here is what I see. A textbook bandwagon. Because if one more person votes no death then the day immediately will end and that is bad for the town. I'll help stop your temptation though Freya.

##Vote:Formalhaut

The night time is the time of the mafia, let's not rush what we have.

[Formalhaut]

Wow a lot happened while I was asleep. Here is what I see. A textbook bandwagon. Because if one more person votes no death then the day immediately will end and that is bad for the town. I'll help stop your temptation though Freya.

##Vote:Formalhaut

The night time is the time of the mafia, let's not rush what we have.

I knew you were out to get me, leafyhead!

A fair point, but what is there to discuss? More circular arguments? Gardening? Favourite pizza toppings? I'm all for talking, but we need something concrete to discuss. And unless someone chucks out a daytime role ability for the funnies, we won't really get a concrete point to discuss until after the night has ended.

Having said that, I suppose there's nothing lost in having the 48 hours play out. But then I can't really see anything gained with having 48 hours play out on Day One either. Maybe I'm just impatient.

Either way though, I'm not going to countervote against you, Qwerty, because while I disagree on stance, yours is obviously committed to thinking about the town's best interests.

Still, it hurts being the first player to be voted. It's almost like you want me dead, or something.

[FFNut]

The reason I voted No Death is we really don't have any info on anyone yet. To take a pop shot at someone early with very little info is both bold and a little silly as it could hurt your chances latter. There is lots of time to kill coming up. No need to rush on half truths and gut feelings... Yet.

[Fynn]

The reason I voted No Death is we really don't have any info on anyone yet. To take a pop shot at someone early with very little info is both bold and a little silly as it could hurt your chances latter. There is lots of time to kill coming up. No need to rush on half truths and gut feelings... Yet.

Yeah, poor Formy

[Formalhaut]

Yeah, you guys, why do you have to be so suspicious of me. It isn't like we're playing a game of Mafia or something.

[FFNut]

Plus you pulled Kefka which is one of the most evil of all villains.

[Freya]

Aerith's Knight has been inactive so far. Wondering if that's deliberate for staying low or he just hasn't checked.

[Scruffington]

Oh flipping heck I thought we moved passed the whole 'let's discuss how we all play Mafia differently' topic. Just let people be people. Let people make perceived errors or mistakes. Let people reveal all, or keep their cards close to their chest. For some people, this is their first time playing Mafia, so let's not bombard them with rule variations and alterations that might confuse them.

The only reason I even brought it up here was because I wanted some context from Shauna about the lack of "no-lynch" option in past games.

Then Freya was trying to put words in my mouth and suggest I said something I clearly hadn't, so I wanted to explain my thoughts further. I didn't have any interest in discussing mafia rules outside of the "no-lynch" part, which is relevant to both this particular game and this specific day.

[Formalhaut]

Eh, I was mainly just venting to no-one in particular. I've been hearing this back and forth in this thread and the last, it kinda gets boring when you think about it

Anyway, yes Freya I was about to comment on Aerith's Knight's absence as well. How long do we actually have left of Day One?

[Freya]

Well in 2 mins it'll have been 24 hrs from the first "GO GO" post so... 24 more hours?

[Formalhaut]

Well in 2 mins it'll have been 24 hrs from the first "GO GO" post so... 24 more hours?

Well, that's plenty of time to micro-analyse every post thus far. Thanks for the time-check Freya!

[Formalhaut]

Talking about checks, it is time for another vote check!

No Death - 4/5 (Fynn, Fox, Formalhaut, FFNut)

Formalhaut - 1/5 (Qwertysaur)

[Freya]

That leaves:

• Scruffington
• Freya
• Aerith's Knight
• Shauna

Having not voted yet.

That being said

##Vote: Shauna

Her pop in recap and pop out was just a bit too brief. Maybe that will get you to join in more, shauna!

I think AK may actually just be inactive

[qwertysaur]

Here is why I'm against no lynching so fast

Firstly it ends the day and that's the time where the mafia can strike, as I've said before

Secondly it's just not sustainable. We need to eventually vote on people to lynch because the mafia are not going to just kill themselves for us. A no lynch is the safest vote for them because it has almost no risk.