Quote Originally Posted by Formalhaut View Post
But just to briefly add to a point I made previously, Karifean said there was 9 players, and 2 mafia. Randomly killing someone with little more reason than "eh, they'll do" has a statistically higher chance of inadvertently killing a town person. This is a bad thing.
Agreed. At this point, by choosing to kill someone at random we have a greater chance of diminishing our own numbers instead of actually hurting the forces of Chaos. And we don't know who has what talent - is there even a protector that stands a chance to protect someone from getting killed at night? This way, we can go from 7 to 5 incredibly fast, which is why I'm fundamentally against lynching on day one.