FFIX Mafia - Discussion thread

[Del Murder]

A pretty close game that came down to the wire. Good job mafia! Some smart kills in particular.

I think the town's biggest mistake in the end was for Steiner to protect Eiko. I think the kill was predictable to not be Eiko due to the existence of protection so the doc had a 33% chance to block the real kill by switching it up.

[Fox]

A pretty close game that came down to the wire. Good job mafia! Some smart kills in particular.

I think the town's biggest mistake in the end was for Steiner to protect Eiko. I think the kill was predictable to not be Eiko due to the existence of protection so the doc had a 33% chance to block the real kill by switching it up.

You can't protect yourself as doc though can you? If so then it couldn't have made any difference as I targeted the doc. Not deliberately​, but still ^^

[Pumpkin]

I thought Eiko and Quina were mafia but it was really just guesses

[Formalhaut]

For me my biggest mistake was not to advocate a no lynch to allow another investigation. Atmosphere got ahead of me, what with everyone's going "the final day" and "decide now!"

I had completely forgotten no lynch was an option.

[Karifean]

For me my biggest mistake was not to advocate a no lynch to allow another investigation. Atmosphere got ahead of me, what with everyone's going "the final day" and "decide now!"

I had completely forgotten no lynch was an option.

Also an option I'm pretty sure would've gotten you a quick defeat. Since it would've meant a free kill for the mafia, the number of town and mafia would've been equal afterwards.

[Del Murder]

You can't protect yourself as doc though can you? If so then it couldn't have made any difference as I targeted the doc. Not deliberately​, but still ^^

That is a stipulation that is used sometimes but not always. I think in a small game like this I would not use it.

[Formalhaut]

Hmm... good point. In that case, biggest mistake was investigating Steiner. Pretty much hinged on that, I guess.

[Karifean]

Hmm... good point. In that case, biggest mistake was investigating Steiner. Pretty much hinged on that, I guess.

Yup. Having your investigation be predictable was the biggest weak point. Had you investigated anyone else, you'd have won instantly. But of course from your point of view it made sense, if you believed Steiner to be the remaining Mafia ^^

[Formalhaut]

In my defence, Steiner was acting pretty fishy.

[Freya]

Yeah you're lucky that off the bat they announced you were a sane cop too. Imagine being insane and not knowing it! You'd have thought everyone was a baddie!

In a bigger game where they have a large roster, and don't list roles, always investigate yourself =x That way you know if your future investigations will be backwards or not.

[qwertysaur]

Unless the mod says you can't investigate yourself. Then you have to think about it more.

[Psychotic]

I think if you're going to have variable sanity then you should allow the cop to investigate themselves. Then you have the trade off as to whether it's worth sacrificing a night or not.

[Freya]

Haha yes! You can be restricted!

[FFNut]

I was wondering if you were going to investigate me really. If you did it may have gone different, but I was sure Steiner was Mafia.