Quote Originally Posted by [M] Beatrix View Post
Except at this point we have nothing to go on. Might as well shoot blindly, hoping we can avenge our fallen comrade.

So far every argument he's used was an appeal to emotion. Nothing convinces me he's not mafia.
What else can Kuja use? We've literally just started the game. And while he's appealing to emotion, aren't you also appealing to emotion as well, namely that of revenge? Some people have barely had any time to make any form of statement yet. A few have only posted once, and that was just to announce they're here.

As we know from arguments made in previous games, shooting blindly is more likely to hit a stray Town than a Mafia. The probability reveals it all.