I'm watching Totalbiscuit streaming this at the moment. I have to say I'm not sure I can get over this level of writing. Unless it gets MUCH better. For example (spoiler from the first couple of hours):
(SPOILER)When Ryder's father dies and she's being told about it. Cora says something like: "I'm afraid your father is dead. That must be a real blow" That must be a blow. Uh, yes. Yes Cora I do think that qualifies as a 'blow,' could you not muster up just a tiny bit more believable human emotion please? You've just told me of my Father's demise in the same tone that you might inform someone that we're out of chocolate chip ice cream.
Let's just say I'll be looking for the reviews to say "It really finds its feet and becomes less consistently cringeworthy later in the game" before I decide to drop full price on this.