Quote Originally Posted by [M] Aigis View Post
And honestly, another thing Akihiko, the most concrete reasoning you've given for suspecting Elizabeth is that she seems scummy to you. Sure, if it's actually just a gut feeling you're going with then fair enough but you're awfully obsessed with that notion despite some better arguments to be made against others. Either you're mafia or you're fishing. Either way I don't buy your complete lack of reasoning against her.
No, that isn't at all what I said. Did you even read my posts?

I said she is suspicious because she has yet to claim a role. Every single other town role in the game has been claimed. There are two other Vanilla Townie roles (claimed by myself and Shinjiro), one Tracker (Junpei), one Doctor (you), and one Cop (Mitsuru).

There aren't any other roles available. She has to be mafia.