Quote Originally Posted by [M] Aigis View Post
First off, you started the day accusing her by simply saying she seems scummy to you.
Yes, because she has been acting fairly aloof and distancing herself from being a huge part of any major discussion. I'm not buying it.

Seriously, if you're trying to convince me that because some people said they're vanilla town she can't be then I'm more convinced than ever you're mafia and she's town because that is the single worst piece of reasoning I've seen this entire game.
I'm speaking from my own point of view, as a Vanilla Townie. Because I am telling the truth, only one of Shinjiro or Elizabeth can be the other Vanilla Townie. Therefore one has to be lying.

Pretty solid reasoning to me. Whether you choose to trust me or not is up to you.

Third, no, of course people outside of the game =/= people inside. But unless you're a sociopath most people have a hard time maintaining false emotions and reactions over a long period of time. And I know what her reacting genuinely looks like. So either she's a damn good actor or I'm trusting my gut for now.
Okay, cool. It's possible that she's telling the truth and that Shinjiro is the one who's lying. But your gut is 100% wrong about me and I can't wait until you realize it.