EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Now I go back to work and cooking.

[Formalhaut]

Being lynched to win would suggest one role: the Jester.

Not impossible, but even the MafiaWiki says not to use them. Having said that, I can't deny the possibility.

[Fynn]

As I said before, I misunderstood part of my role PM, which is why I was reluctant to reveal my statement right away. One the halftime write-up appeared, I reread the mognet and found out I was wrong. The write-up was also constructed in such a way that I figured I could benefit everyone by revealing my statement at that point.

I'm not saying you revealing your statement is incriminating. Honestly, I didn't suspect you at first, but then Pumpkin and Formy pointed out things that made me doubt you. And I also stated my reasoning against a no lynch for this specific game in the other thread - with so many potentially town-hurting powers, even on townies, it's really safer for us to get rid of someone rather than vote no lynch. I'm open to changing my mind if you can convince me otherwise, though

[Formalhaut]

Thanks for your input TSoL!

Having said that, I'm still not hundred-percent on the theory that Carny is a witch. Only one of the abilities are obviously to do with writing (rewrite).

With that being the case, why would he still say three players have the ability to alter the writeups? I guess there's the possibility that he goofed, but that's a pretty simple error to goof up on, and it wouldn't have happened in the first place if he stuck to there being one person who can alter the writeups.

[Fynn]

Formy, why are you defending him so vehemently even though he's not even the top suspect and the main topic of discussion at this point?

[Fynn]

Even if he goofed, he still screwed with the statement. If he's not a witch or a cynic, he cannot alter them in any way. Unless, of course, it turns out there are more roles that can do it

[FFNut]

I counted two on my vision including Karifean. If he did the same then thought possibility the cynic as a writer. It would give him three.

[Formalhaut]

He's the current person of discussion at the moment? TSoL and others have accused him of being a witch, something I'm not convinced of myself at the moment, so I'm saying why I'm not that convinced.

Whether or not that is 'vehement' is up to you to decide. All I can say is, Carny's guilt or innocence has been brought up as a topic of discussion and I'm responding to it.

[FFNut]

That is just my thought.

[Formalhaut]

Well, to clarify, TSoL thinks he's a Jester, which is basically an anti-town role, and Nutty is suspicious of him. I don't see it, myself.

[Fynn]

To me it's just weird how you seem to simply reject the fact that that behavior is suspicious in the least. I use the term "vehement" because you're trying to convince us he's 100% clean, even though you have no basis at all to believe so. Nobody aside from you is convinced - at least not to that degree - that the sacrifice thing is done with good intentions

[FFNut]

You may be bias, but to me he just doesn't add up. Something is off.

[Pumpkin]

Its hard not to turn on people in situations like this that breed distrust. It stands out to me how aggressively anti-Carny FFNut is, and TSoL was quick to point his finger that way as well. But I don't like distrusting people on pretty weak suspicions, honestly. I feel like I need more info before I can make a more educated guess as to who the witch(es) is/are

[FFNut]

It could be said for him though that he may be using the same Tatics Scruff used in the last game by being so aggressive that he has to be town.

[Fynn]

Formy, either you don't see it because you're biased, or you know something we don't.

I don't think we need to go into the latter, but if it's the former, remember this is mafia - we've been assigned roles randomly and we're all constantly evolving our playstyles. You can't rely on preconceptions and rule out a possibility based on that. Trust no one - the golden rule of mafia