EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[Fynn]

Every witch also has an avility that is not killing

[Pumpkin]

Yeah that would make my theory of TSoL being a witch wrong because guy in the hall would have been called candy. Unless interference in some way. I guess if it was a mass role-block mine wouldn't have had effect either and TSoL would have remained candyless

But then again I also believe Nutty to be a witch and he could have been the one to execute the action instead of TSoL. They do have their own abilities to use that they can't use if they kill, so they might have decided to just have him do nothing or use his other ability

[Pumpkin]

Wait why would Fynn have two abilities from two different characters?

[Formalhaut]

And of course if I'm wrong on the mass-roleblock then the entire thing falls apart as the rewriting roles get to have some fun.

But if no mass-roleblock went through, then how did no-one die? Again, possible that the witches did nothing. Or one re-write acted like a janitor, but even then I'm sure Karifean would indicate that 'someone' died, as the barest minimum for a kill writeup.

I don't know. I've said what I feel about the writeup, and I don't think we're going to make any headway with it unless someone roleclaims.

For now though:

##Vote: FFNut

For the tunnelling of Mr. Carny (who I believe is likely to be Town) despite other possible points of suspicion. The dodgy sounding Purple Statement and accusing Pumpkin without much cause.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Wait why would Fynn have two abilities from two different characters?

I said he was targeted by two abilities. I can see what people are targeted with.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Stealth coincides with the person hiding in the shadows.

[Pumpkin]

Ohhh okay I thought you said he HAD those two abilities, my bad

[Formalhaut]

And Pumpkin could easily be Pained and now she triggered it and she's out to get everyone. Pained can roleclaim to activate themselves.

I have an ability that allows me to see what abilities are performed on others. From that list, I can ask for one to be explained. I targeted Fynn. He had Intimidate and Stealth. I asked about the former. I was told it can be used to one shot prevent from a nightlife or use regularly a protect one person like a doctor. This is why when Fynn denied a mass protect ability I found it weird, because from the narrative and what I got that's exactly what happened. Plus the rest of Fynn's argument relies on highly conditional stuff that seemed improbable and too much conjecture. Like no nightkill would be weird.

Could you explain? I'm fairly stupid.

So you can see what abilities are performed on others? So are you saying Fynn was intimidated and stealthed?

[Fynn]

Woah

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Also, Pumpkin how do we not know you're a Pained. If you are Pained then your roleclaim just triggered it.

[Formalhaut]

Kinda have it explained now. Thanks!

I'm curious what Stealth does, to be honest. It sounds quite vague.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Also I'm at work :/

[Pumpkin]

I mean, I wasn't told I was pained. I imagine I'd get a message or something. Could be Karifean hasn't read my roleclaim and hasn't informed me yet if that's the case

So basically if I wasn't told at the beginning then I know about as much as you do when it comes to that!

[Formalhaut]

If Pumpkin is the Pained, I'm not sure she would trigger it voluntarily. Winning as a Serial Killer is tough, as you've got to play just well enough to not get lynched from suspicion, but not too well so you're not nightkilled. And this is literally her first game. That's a baptism of fire.

[Formalhaut]

Of course, she might not be told she is the Pained. But that sounds kinda dickish to have that hidden from you.