That's what I think, but goodness who knows in this game. It is almost always assumed that Mafia/witches have factional communication. It'd be very interesting if there was some mechanic affecting this.Originally Posted by Mr. Carnelian
Process of elimination. Mafia always get told who else is mafia. Therefore, everyone who they AREN'T told is mafia must be non-mafia. God, it's the Akihiko "How many townies are there?" question all over again!How do you know this?
As for Scruffy's vote? I think Mr. Carny just assumed Mafia could communicate and worked off of that assumption. It is such a basic rule I didn't even notice it wasn't on Karifean's OP, which doesn't necessarily mean anything in and of itself.
Let's not forget the slim-yet-possible chance that there might be a third party unaligned between Town and Mafia. Roles like Serial Killers and Survivors exist, though they are fairly rare in the EoFF meta.
