Quote Originally Posted by Formalhaut View Post
That's what I think, but goodness who knows in this game. It is almost always assumed that Mafia/witches have factional communication. It'd be very interesting if there was some mechanic affecting this.

As for Scruffy's vote? I think Mr. Carny just assumed Mafia could communicate and worked off of that assumption. It is such a basic rule I didn't even notice it wasn't on Karifean's OP, which doesn't necessarily mean anything in and of itself.

Let's not forget the slim-yet-possible chance that there might be a third party unaligned between Town and Mafia. Roles like Serial Killers and Survivors exist, though they are fairly rare in the EoFF meta.
As I said, it's a normal assumption to make.

His post didn't suggest that he was assuming this was the case. His post seemed to indicate a certainty that the mafia can communicate with each other, and we have no evidence that this is the case.