I understand the 'gaining our trust' mechanic but Pumpkin was fairly low down at least my suspicion list so to take a risky gambit like that would've been foolish to say the least.
I understand the 'gaining our trust' mechanic but Pumpkin was fairly low down at least my suspicion list so to take a risky gambit like that would've been foolish to say the least.
Especially since I really think it isn't reasonable to take such a risk this early in the game
It's why I find it hard to believe Mr. Carny is a witch, after making several unforced errors at the very start of the day. There was literally no reason for him to stick his neck out in the most ungainful fashion.
I also find Pumpkin to be registering lower down my list because her purple statement was the first to mention a cynic, and is backed up by two other statements. Even if one of those statements is a lie, the other corroborates it.
I have class soon but let's try and organize our suspicions a bit. These are the suspicions that I seem to recall have been raised. Feel free to correct me if I remember wrong
Pumpkin:
-Revealed role which could mean she's pained and go on a serial killing spree
-Deductions may have been stretched
-May have tried to perform a night kill
FFNut:
-Reacted very poorly to being put under suspicion
-Sketchy defensive for himself and his role
-Selective focus on purple statements
-Purple statement that doesn't seem to suit the narrative
Fynn:
-Conveniently timed purple statement that adds to a previously mentioned statement
Formy:
-Staunch defense of Mr. Carny
Scruffington:
-Refusal to state purple statement
Laddy:
-A lot of time absent
TSoL:
-A purple statement that seems to contradict other parts of the game narrative
-Weird phrasing in the purple statement
Quin:
-MIA
Mr. Carny:
-Sticking his neck out as a sacrifice
-Aggressive play
Just because it is Pumpkin doesn't mean she couldn't be playing us all. I mean she's the last person you'd think to do it so what better cover is there?
Also, the style of my statement isn't weird since I copied and pasted it from Karifean. So there's that.
Urgh why is it busy today!?
In the same vein, just because you say you cut and paste your statement doesn't mean you're telling the truth. I really wish people would stop implying I can't play the game because I can't see past friendships. That's the second time that's happened now and it is more than a little insulting.
To be honest, I would be far more suspicious of Pumpkin if she roleclaimed unprovoked. Nutty did vote for her saying she did something, so her claiming in defence makes sense.
Of course, that's also the perfect opportunity to claim safely and trigger yourself. But then, I still don't think someone would want to become a SK unless they absolutely must. At this point, we're just getting circular arguments.
To be fair, Karifean did use "the purple" when revealing his truth
Originally Posted by Karifean
Very true and a good observation. It could be he used 'the purple' because by that point it was the end of the day and everyone knew what he meant. I'd suspect in a Role PM at the very start of the first Day for him to use full terminology to avoid confusion, but who knows. That certainly brings into doubt suspicion over his Role PM.
I'd also like to point out that that statement pretty much confirms that Karifean views himself as a player
Oh my God Karifean's a witch. Burn him!
Maybe not, but he may just be one of the players who can influence the wite-ups
(i'd also like to point out how different scruff's playstyle is this time around though that may not mean anything just saying)
Of course I am a witch. I am the Witch of Theatergoing, didn't you know?
Do we break the game if we burn Karifean the witch? Do we enter into an alternate reality?
I just would like to come clean about something. Pumkin has seen that Bobby and I have been Mognnetting each other and this is her whole base on both of us. I am going to Montreal in July and asked if he and his boyfriend wanted to meet up for dinner while I am there which they accepted. So voting off Pumkins theory is a vote for me meeting Bobby for Dinner. Just tossing that out there.
Posting Permissions
