One witch doesn't seem like much but I guess if the Cynic is on their side, it would make what Formy said about their being around 2 witches for this size game accurate. Even if one technically isn't a witch. And if there is only one witch, they wouldn't have to worry about communicating with others about killing. But then again, why would there specifically be a rule about if more than one tries to kill, it will cancel out? Seems like a weird thing to add when only one person can kill.

That's also 3 truths that all relate to the same thing, which seems like it might be a bit much. Maybe I'm just being paranoid but some of this is just not clicking for me.

So if I'm understanding correctly, there is a cynic player who wants to kill the townies like a witch but probably can't kill, although they might know who the witch(es) are, but they don't know who the cynic is. Which could mean that the cynic might have sent the message to a witch. Also the cynic might be able to lie and would probably come up as a townie if investigated.