The main reason I find Mr. Carny to not be that suspicious (besides him being my boyfriend, of course ) is that he was very willing to sacrifice himself to resolve a tie and prove or disprove my Purple Statement.

I mean it could be a bluff and he's a witch trying to make himself look super-innocent, but if we called him on his bluff and decided that - yes, we do actually want to try that out - he would either have to go along with it and risk being lynched or back out and thus look pretty darn suspicious.

I just don't see a witch making such a death-defying leap like that, especially on Day One when the stakes aren't even that high.