Don't really believe the mass roleblock theory. I am, however, more and more inclined to believe there are more witches, which is why having three people to mask their movements easier. So I'm not so convinced Carny lied anymore. My main theory at the moment is that each person can alter a different aspect of the write-up.

The reason why nobody died is obvious, then - they all used their abilities instead in order to get as much information about everyone possible which, considering all the weird rules, would benefit them. A lot.

I also agree that we should be careful with the Pained. I propose that we don't try to figure out what the actual identities are, at least not at this stage, since I still think it's still possible for us to deduce people's skills without deducing their identities. Of course, it's still possible that someone privately finding out their identity is enough, but we can't do anything about that anyway, so we can only hope