Nutty's truth was that there was two Human-aligned Pained. Now you can say that I am lying, but this is why I am offering this deal and said what I have said to show you I am telling the truth and willing to work with the humans since we share a goal.

Also, you know I am a witch and I will come up a witch if there is a cop. I have no allies in this group at the moment except for the Cynic which I am offering up because it is my win condition and without my co-operation you will have more difficult time figuring who that out is.

Put it this way, as we stand right now treating mean like a Pained or treating me like a Witch is the same thing. What I am offering here is chance to work together and for me to prove myself. I do not have a nightkill ability and I am offering my Deduced ability to the collective service.