Quote Originally Posted by The Summoner of Leviathan View Post
My plan was always to betray Nutty and Scruff just happened sooner than later. Giving up the Cynic was the only way I could spin it with a chance to win.
You were already outed as mafia in multiple ways though. Nutty outed you, you outed yourself, I posted my Red Truth, and then you directly confirmed you were mafia by stating that you've seen the PM (which only a Witch can receive).

So I was always meant to betray. My hand moved a bit faster than I would have liked but what I did seemed my only viable move to my win. A witch victory wouldn't have been a victory for me. So I was never on anyone's side but my own. I was essentially Pained witch already activated, not a reverse Cynic.
Yeah you were meant to betray, but offing another mafia when there are still 5 townies left in the game is a pretty bad decision. You did it to buy yourself an extra day in a game that you were inevitably going to lose.

Quote Originally Posted by Pumpkin View Post
I think TSoL did really well at defending himself after FFNut got offed. The game wasn't as over as I thought it was
Nutty put him in an unfortunate position (and one that town should not have trusted him from considering he was outed as mafia by Nutty). He also incriminated himself in multiple ways and a few pieces of evidence against him.

Anyways, thanks again for hosting Karifean. Not sure if my game will have quite the same flavor in write-ups as yours, but I'll see if I can learn a thing or two from you. :P