I agree with your views on the whole! I agree on a couple of your lower ones Lightning and Vaan. I think Vaan isn't a dislikeable character but as you say, he's just kinda there. I'm also glad Cecil is high, I think he's a really underrated character. The only one I'd really liked to see significantly bumped up (I am a massive Cloud fanboy of course but #3 is a fine spot) is actually Noctis. The wider story of XV is kind of eh but the four bros are all wonderful. XV ENDING spoilers!The last emotional line to his bros around the campfire is probably one of the most powerful and, well, as I said, emotional moments in FF history.