Tales of Mafia XXXI - Super Fun Game Thread

[[M] Anise]

As for role analysis, it seems pretty clear to me that if we have either a doctor or a jailkeeper but not both and two roles canceled each other out night one that we almost certainly have no doctor and the jailkeeper and roleblocker targeted each other. And this is assuming, of course, that there's only one roleblocker. If there are two then there may still be a doctor and no jailkeeper.

Now if I'm right and there's a jailkeeper but no doctor, and the jailkeeper and the roleblocker canceled each other out, then they most likely chose not to night kill hoping to convince the jailkeeper they chose correctly night one. But if there is just the one roleblocker, and assuming they're mafia as there tends to often be a mafia roleblocker, the jailkeeper might very well know the identity of the mafia roleblocker right now which is pretty important.

That is a good point Anise. And with skits especially things may get away from them if they don't act every night.

Also, if the roleblocker and jailer canceled each other, we also have to face the fact that they know who the jailer is and will be gunning for them. That would be a bad role to lose early on.

What? Two roles cancelled each other out last night. Which to me means that two roles that could block abilities cancelled each other out. As in jail keeper targets role blocker, and their abilities to block roles cancel out and nothing happens.

I'm a little suspicious, to be honest! We have either a Jailkeeper or a Doctor, and now Colette is claiming to be Jailkeeper, so assuming she is telling the truth we have effectively lost our only protective role.

I'm kinda confused why she decided to roleclaim when she did. I didn't see any obvious tells that she was a Jailkeeper, if I'm honest.

I dunno, I'm inclined to believe them they've been dropping the same line several times now, hinting toward there being a jailkeeper. I could be completely duped about this, though.

Only thing I can for see is that they were doing this to set up a roleclaim. If they were mafia and knew a jailkeeper blocked them, plus with the cancelling out info, they may have been trying to cement their role? Maybe? That's possibly what I could gather if they were lying.