Bracket One : Nathan Drake (Uncharted series) Joel looks like he could easily be your Dad and WELL that's awkward.
Bracket Two : Booker DeWitt (Bioshock Infinite) I love his red scarf. 10/ 10 very cute.
Bracket Three : The Prince (Prince of Persia, the 2008 version) Snake will always be at work and never home. He will never be at your kids football games or be at their birthday parties. Every year he'll just send a budget birthday card in the mail. That's not acceptable. The Prince might be the same, but like, he has a good scarf so it's more forgivable.
Bracket Four : Alvin (Tales of Xilia) The other guy has that "white male protag look " that you see in almost every modern game.