Caprica, making a list of suspects and saying "I know these people are scum." with out much reason doesn't mean you might be a jester, it means you might be mafia. Aggressively attacking people, and leading the charge on mis-lynches makes you look like a Jester. Which is what Roslin has been doing. You're just following along like her obedient little lap dog.

So Caprica/Roslin are somehow unable to see a way where Dee is town. Roslin says she "knows", in much the same way I assume she "knew" Apollo was mafia. Caprica follows along because the player typically follows loud, brash players, and it also keeps votes off of her. They really are quite the team right now.

I'm more reasonable. The main reason I'm voting Caprica is because of her previous voting behavior and her current inability to admit even possibility that she's wrong on her scum reads on myself, Dee, and Felix. Versus what we have on Dee which is really pure speculation and trusting Roslin, who I find to be untrustworthy for reasons I've already stated several times.

However, if I'm wrong, and it turns out a lynch vote on Dee shows she's scum, then you should indeed suspect me next. I'm a town trying to read the situation as best as I can, but I admit it will look scummy if Dee turns out to be mafia, and I should go accordingly. It just makes sense.