Quote Originally Posted by [M] Gaius View Post
I do know Roslin had some suspicions about him though I didn't quite follow, could you explain that a bit more Roslin, or is it already obsolete?
Sure. A lot of my suspicion is hinging on the two of them apparently collaborating together in Day 2. I was more suspicious of Dee than Adama, he just seemed to associate himself a bit too closely with her. I was also following along with Caprica's reasoning because I agreed with them.

Roslin
Conduct: Town
Evidence: Town

Nothing so far in Roslin's conduct has actually made me think she's scum. She's been aggressively pulling people out of their comfort zones and getting as much information circling as possible. People like to say that's what Mafia do to confuse things, but really in my experience it's more often the other way round, especially in EoFF games so far - Mafia are usually not the ones aggressively leading the charge. And it's also just gonna get you investigated and tracked to hell and back and yet nobody has come forward with a Guilty on her. Also of course gets Town evidence by virtue of being protected by Tigh in a night with no Town deaths.
Thanks for the vote of confidence. This definitely is what I'm trying to accomplish.

I actually happen to agree with a majority of your reads. This doesn't mean there's no possibility of you being scum from my POV, but we seem to be thinking along the same lines.


Quote Originally Posted by [M] Aaron View Post
Seems a little strange to say that all Roslin is doing is pulling people out of their comfort zones when that's half the truth at best. If all she were doing was scum hunting I'd actually agree with you. But so far they've yet to have a good read on anyone. They were wrong about Apollo, they lied about Dee, and now we're expected to trust them when they almost got a person lynched based on their lies and haven't offered much in the way of solid reads otherwise?
What you're doing is pretty scummy, honestly.

I was wrong about Apollo, but I was right about Athena. You're also neglecting to mention that I had a strong townread of Caprica and worked alongside her, and she ended up flipping town on Day 2. I have been proven to be correct about 2/3 of my "final" reads so far.

You also keep suggesting I "lied" about Dee, when I keep telling you I "bluffed" a result on her. You're trying to throw shade and misconstrue my intent, and that's super not cool.

At this point it honestly seems like you're trying desperately to steer the vote away from Dee by throwing me under the bus.

I'm willing to team up with Gaius and abandon my idea of the Dee-Adama scumteam. Aaron just seems far too tunneled on me, to a degree where he's actively trying to mislead people about my gameplay in an effort to make me look scummy.

##Unvote
##Vote: Aaron