Okay, Day Two. We've narrowed down the suspect pool now, so goodbye Lady Luck. No more letting the dice do the talking.

Quote Originally Posted by [M] D'Anna View Post
Athena was the one who brought it up though. I think this vindicates roslin. Athena must have been hunting for another mafia and tried to hit early when she thought that's what was happening.
For all we know, that WAS what was happening. Roslin could still be mafia. My gut says they're town, but she's not completely off my radar yet.

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Dee View Post
I don't like how Caprica swung the vote off Roslin near end of day and on Apollo either. We ended up killing a valuable town, and Roslin had enough suspicion on her that there was a good chance they'd be lynched later anyway, especially if Apollo flipped town. I'd probably want to lynch Caprica before Roslin because of this reason.
I was REALLY surprised when the lynch swung to Apollo. It just seemed to come out of nowhere. And maybe I'm reading Caprca's vote post wrong, but it seems like she was basing it mostly on Roslin's say-so. Why trust Roslin so much on the first day?

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Caprica View Post
Also are there 2 scum teams? I see two dead, but if we don't know the abilities it could be a passive Town protection that killed her and saved one of us?
Bringing up genuine possibilities, or trying to throw us off the scent? I'm watching you, Caprica.