Quote Originally Posted by [M] Gaius View Post
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Roslin View Post
The difference between yesterday and today is that I have concrete information that leads me to believe you're scum. That's why I'm saying "Dee is scum" as opposed to going off of Day 1 scumreads, like I did with Apollo and Athena.

It's called hinting. I'm not giving you any more information. You're not going to fish my role out of me. Stop trying.
Telling us everything we need to know. It's an assertion not speculation, meaning Roslin has definitive information to say Dee is scum, either that or she's lying and trying to get Dee lynched which will be revealed at nightfall, so since we're still doing pretty well...

##Vote: Dee
I believe I'll have to agree with the good Doctor Baltar on this. Assuming the numbers work out (for recreational reasons I can't actually do the math just in case I am wrong), it's a bold play but one that could come with high reward if Dee is a toaster. And I despite Apollo Roslin did turn me onto the Athena route day one and I still don't know if I buy that they're anything more than scum hunting. Aggressively perhaps but still.

And I think we should hear more from D'Anna in addition to the others mentioned.

I also find Caprica's certainty strange. Maybe it's a false bravado that comes from that place of desperately trying not to get lynched, but we have 2-3 people who have been rather inactive or unhelpful who none of us can be at all sure about, and she's sure enough to name everyone but them as who they think is mafia? And saying it with a strange degree of certainty? I don't buy it. She may have outed Dee realizing Roslin could have something on her as one of them, but this feels like trying to spread some focus away. If Caprica flips mafia in the end I'd say at least one if not two of the quieter folks are mafia as well.

I'll hold off for a bit but I'm leaning voting for Dee but could almost as easily go Caprica. We'll see what happens.