Quote Originally Posted by [M] Dee View Post
Please share your concrete information, because I don't believe you have any. It's easy to say "I know X is scum because reasons I won't out" because nobody can prove or disprove anything one way or the other. Whereas something like "I know X is scum because I have Y role and insert thing here happened" is more dangerous. You can be counter claimed. You can also have another player catch you in a lie. For example if you say "I am the tracker, I saw player X visit dead player Y last night, they were the only one to do so" then another player besides X could come in and say "I am the cop, I also visited player Y" and catch you in a lie. Your refusal to share isn't helping your case. Still, I find it unlikely you're scum at the moment because you'd have to know I'd flip town and you'd just get lynched. So either you're jester and want to be lynched, or you are executioner with me as your target (you shaded me on day 1, and are hard pushing me today).
No thanks.

This is a closed setup, meaning there could be multiples of roles. I could hypothetically reveal myself as a tracker, and a counter claim wouldn't necessarily mean anything. It's entirely possible there are multiples of roles.

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Roslin View Post
I'm just going to throw your words back at you here since you don't seem to see what a hypocrite you're being.
Except I'm not.

You're asking me to reveal my role. I'm asking you to say yes or no, to an ambiguous question. But your refusal to answer is already telling as is.

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Roslin View Post
If you're ready to share your "concrete information" then I'm probably going to be forced to role claim since I think I know what you're trying to do. But I doubt you will roleclaim yourself since you know there's a good chance it backfires, so for now I don't feel the need to.
FWIW, the role you're claiming isn't necessarily town. There were two nightkills, meaning it's entirely possible your role isn't town-aligned.