Quote Originally Posted by [M] Dee View Post
Roslin, Caprica, Gaius; I have a question for you 3.

When I flip town, who are you going to look at next? If Caprica is the lynch today and they flip town, I'm certain I bite the bullet the next day. If I get lynched I'm assuming most people go for Caprica or Roslin tomorrow (despite my wishes) but seeing as you obviously aren't going for yourselves and seem to have quite the tight little group there...who next? Will you still suspect Adamma after I'm cleared as town? Will you vote Felix? Someone else entirely? Go after each other? I want to know who each of you would vote next and why. Roslin won't give a reason for my lynch ("concrete evidence" without presenting said evidence isn't a reason, that would never hold up in court) Gaius is following Roslin based on said "evidence" without further question, and as far as I can tell Caprica is voting me for refusing to roleclaim when Roslin is doing the same thing. As much as I want to believe I have 3 non-town on my train even I have to admit one of you could very well be town, and I'd like to figure out who that is so I can my final reads on everyone in before I kick the bucket.
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Dee View Post
Gaius/Caprica: Does it truly not bother you that Roslin votes people seemingly at random with little or no explanation given? If I said I had "hard evidence" against someone yet refused to provide it, I doubt you would blindly follow me; what has Roslin done that makes them town enough in your eyes to follow her? Especially considering she scumread you both day 1, I'd expect you to be at least slightly wary of her. Why do you read her as town when she won't elaborate on her reads?
I don't think of myself as part of a group with Roslin and Caprica, really... I just don't see a reason not to give Roslin the benefit of the doubt regarding her supposed evidence.

If you'd said you had hard evidence of course I would have followed you. The death announcement will reveal whether or not you were telling the truth after all, so it's at worst a scum-town trade which I'd consider worth it right now. Admittedly though the possibility of Roslin being a Jester setting things up for her own execution is one that slipped my mind. Thanks for bringing that up.

Normally of course I'd go for Roslin next if you flip town because that makes her confident statement a blatant lie. With the possibility of her being a jester on the board though I might have to rethink things if it gets to that point. Either way it's still very possible that she's actually a town cop or something along those lines and got a guilty result on you. It's a risk I'm willing to take.

Gaius/Roslin: Do you not think it's strange that Caprica suddenly flipped the lynch off Roslin onto a power role with little time before end of day, especially since their switch would have tied the votes if nobody else had moved theirs? Do you think it's strange they stated Aaron was a high scum read at the start of day, but have since switched to believing scum is instead me/felix/adama despite no real evidence being given for it? (Or any evidence given as to why Aaron is suddenly a town read if that's the case?)
I don't think it's particularly strange to be honest, at least not for who I believe to be the person in question. As of now I think her actions are just par for course.

Also, regardless of them being scum or not, Apollo being a power role was something they hardly could have known at the time, now was it? I see little reason to read so deeply into that.

If more than 1 of you is town I'm going to be very disappointed.
It would be quite tragically hilarious if all four of us are actually town and Roslin's assertion was wrong for some trivial reason xD