Quote Originally Posted by [M] Adama View Post
It's real simple why I'm voting for you Caprica. Three people voted Apollo. You, Roslin, and Starbuck.
Town lynching town on Day 1? Wow, color me shocked. It's almost like that's the most probable outcome.

If anything, I suspect the ones who either didn't vote anyone (yourself) or didn't participate in the lynch in order to avoid any suspicion.

Roslin is probably a Jester, and you?
Where did this idea of me being a Jester even come from? Because I scumhunted? That's some seriously bad reasoning. And it just so happens that you and Dee are both hard pushing this angle.

Plus there's the meta game.
You can't base every game off of "meta."

Which is why I was waiting to hear Dee's thoughts. I may have moved my vote depending on how things go.
Why do you have to "wait" to hear Dee's thoughts? Why don't you pressure her yourself, or even suspect her yourself?

Your approach to her is entirely too passive and too lenient compared to what you're trying to do with other players.

I asked Roslin's reasons for voting her, and asked Dee to defend herself. That way I could see what I thought.
You asked Dee, but you didn't ask me. You tried pressuring me. Huge distinction there.

Quote Originally Posted by [M] Adama View Post
Caprica, making a list of suspects and saying "I know these people are scum." with out much reason doesn't mean you might be a jester, it means you might be mafia. Aggressively attacking people, and leading the charge on mis-lynches makes you look like a Jester. Which is what Roslin has been doing. You're just following along like her obedient little lap dog.
No, it doesn't make you look like a Jester. It makes you look like a town player who's trying to win.

So Caprica/Roslin are somehow unable to see a way where Dee is town. Roslin says she "knows", in much the same way I assume she "knew" Apollo was mafia.
Yep. Difference between the Apollo lynch and today is that Night 1 happened.

Versus what we have on Dee which is really pure speculation and trusting Roslin, who I find to be untrustworthy for reasons I've already stated several times.
K. Good luck with that.