Mafia XXXII - BSG Mafia Game Thread - Day Four: Blood and Chrome (Town Victory)

[[M] Adama]

My reasoning is my own.

There's plenty of a basis for possible Jester/Lyncher. Day one, you claimed pretty much everyone was mafia. That's standard practice for you, though. After leading the charge and getting Apollo lynched day one, you made a strong claim to get Dee lynched, and you now claim you had no basis for. It was supposedly a bluff. However, you expected people to take you completely at your word with no explanation and decided those who didn't would be likely scum. Even after you were already wrong on the first lynch.

You lied about your solid Dee evidence, which it appears I was correct to doubt the voracity of, and now you expect people to accept that and trust you on who to go after next? You're basically suggesting punishing people for not trusting you, when they clearly had good reason not to trust you. Your weird behavior lead to a split between groups that helped get a VT lynched because you thought everyone who was a good guy would just trust you.

Maybe your are just a townie with the tact and subtlety of a nail bat, but if there's any reasoning that sounds insane right now it's yours. It still seems like Jester/Lyncher to me.

Go ahead and lead the charge for my lynching too. I can admit it makes a certain amount of sense right now. I'm just really curious to see what your brilliant rationalizing will be when it turns out I'm not what you think I am.