Pushing to see how people react is a good tactic. Faking a red scan or whatever you were bluffing is pushing it. It can be effective in the hands of a skilled player, but more often than not it just ends up with a lot of town needlessly dead, especially when you don't retract your claim after you seen how everyone has responded and before they're actually about to die. If I had got killed and flipped, would you really expect anyone to believe you faked it to test a theory? Pretty much the only thing I can agree with you on is that we likely don't have a vig, as if we did I'd have expected them to shoot me. But mafia are dying somehow. So either there are or 2 factions (which I'm doubting now, as both mafia flips haven't indicated that this is the case) or we have a veteran or some other town killing role. Maybe a re-directer that's making them kill themselves.