Mafia XXXII - BSG Mafia Game Thread - Day Four: Blood and Chrome (Town Victory)

[[M] Kurt - Cool Dad]

You really need to take your own advice. You haven't refuted a single thing.

I've responded to every single one of your posts, and every point against me. So yeah, I have refuted everything.

Your entire argument hinges on Tigh being a doctor and protecting you. But none of us knows for certain there is even a doctor in the game which is my point.

I agree, there's no certainty that there's a doctor in the game. But it makes complete sense for there to be a doctor. It's a staple mafia role, and their gameplay actually fits the bill. They claimed the role at a time where it would potentially expose mafia, which is exactly what a doctor should do.

This leads me to believe Tigh is the doctor.

But because it would be convenient for you if it's true you pretend that it's a forgone conclusion. You essentially claim there's definitely a doctor, it has to be Tigh and he had to have protected you. But it's all based on an assumption. A fact you keep trying to pretend isn't true.

We're into Day 3 now. This is the time where we need to start roleclaiming if we have information. You're right to be skeptical, but I think you're being a bit TOO skeptical.

Honestly, no townie would be convinced of any role being in a closed game with no evidence if they're on their game. They may run with it for a time until it's verified in some way but it hasn't been and if you pretend otherwise you're lying. Add that on top of your other lies and misinformation and I'm even less convinced your town. If you are you're a townie who's every bit as dangerous as any mafia member to us.

And no townie would be convinced that there definitely ISN'T a role in a closed game with no evidence on if they're not in the game. You could use the exact same logic to counter your own point.

My main argument is that there's more than enough reason to believe there IS a doctor in this game, and there's reason to believe that doctor is Tigh.

Also, what other "lies and misinformation" are you even talking about? I BLUFFED once, explicitly owned up to it, and that's it. There aren't any lies. There's no misinformation.

In case it wasn't clear, I have no evidence there's no doctor but it's a possibility since we don't know the roles in play and I recognize it's possible. You have no proof there is a doctor but act as if it's unassailable fact to the point of asking me to prove it false. No townie would be that convinced based on nothing but Tighs word.

It's more likely that there's a doctor than it is that there is no doctor. If you have proof, or you are the doctor, speak up and counter claim him. Otherwise I'm going to take Tigh at his word because it makes little sense not to.

It's amazing how sensitive you are. I haven't moved my vote specifically to do my part to avoid any potential mafia shenanigans because, as I already stated, Tigh's claim matches well enough. It's the most firm claim we have to go on right now.

It has nothing to do with being "sensitive." Don't really know where that is coming from. I'm questioning you because you were acting really dodgy about the doctor claim.

Why aren't you more worried about the people that haven't voted at all, if this is such a concern to you? Why not just wait for Helo to post?

I have no problem with waiting for Helo to post. It just seemed like you were trying to distance yourself from the lynch.