Quote Originally Posted by [M] Felix View Post
Tigh, I don't find your arguments for your survival convincing. Of course mafia would take out a confirmed town doctor as soon as possible. There's no good reason for them not to.
Quote Originally Posted by [M] Adama View Post
Scenario C) We have one mafia team and they are all 1 or 2 shot versions of different mafia PRs. That means we probably only have the godfather left. They've been trying to find town's PR role that keeps eliminating them, but they're struggling to get around a town doctor and a town vigilante who have been just kicking ass. Obviously this would mean the town PRs are not just one or two shot variants of their roles. If that's the case, what are the odds the godfather has any additional abilities?
Except for this bit right here. The scenario of one mafia team means they can only target one person a night. It seems like a possible vigilante could be decimating their ranks, and they've perhaps tried to target that person instead of the possible doctor.

Even if he is a mafia doctor, he could still be protecting himself from night lynches while a vigilante/whatever PR is allowed to run amok.

Quote Originally Posted by Aaron
Gaius visited Helo (I assume to night kill?) and also visited Tigh, presumably to watch them and see if they're really the doctor? Or perhaps they thought he was a second mafia? I don't really know what to think just yet.
Assuming Aaron is telling the truth, this is interesting. And as for Dee.

Quote Originally Posted by Dee
I do believe we have two identical mafia teams now. D'anna was a two shot mafia watcher. Gaius was a two shot mafia watcher. Athena was a one shot mafia doctor. I'm willing to bet our last mafia member is a one shot doctor as well. And we all know who the doc claim is...

If he was a town doc he would be dead. He's still alive. Aaron can track him if you kill me today, I bet he shows up at the door of the next dead player. If aaron dies, it's because said "doc" refused to heal him.
Which is important. You'd assume if Tigh is a one shot doctor, and the other team didn't know this, that he'd be dead by now. The only way I can see him being alive is if he's a town doctor with unlimited heals, he's used up his one shot heal and the other mafia all died before they could get him, or he's just some how been a luckily ignored one-shot mafia doctor with their one heal left.