Mafia XXXII - BSG Mafia Game Thread - Day Four: Blood and Chrome (Town Victory)

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Dee, some of your points makes me remember what Aaron said about his Tracker claim:

I followed Gaius last night. Gaius visited Helo (I assume to night kill?) and also visited Tigh, presumably to watch them and see if they're really the doctor? Or perhaps they thought he was a second mafia? I don't really know what to think just yet.

It's possible that both Aaron and I are telling the truth, we're both town, and this claim makes sense in that context. However it is not possible that both of us are scum: 3 toasters are dead out of 4. If you believe Aaron is lying Cylon scum, that exonerates me by default.

If you do believe him, then we know that toaster scumbag extraordinaire Gaius fracking Baltar visited me. That proves I am not on the same team as Gaius, and also explains why I am still alive: he wanted to check my alignment for whatever reason. If we assume Aaron is telling the truth here, this is what has happened:

- Day 3: 2 Cylons are left. I role claim as town doctor.
- At night, Gaius visits Helo (who ends up dead) and myself.
- The fact that I was visited by a cylon explains why they didn't kill me: they wanted to know if I was an enemy cylon faction or a town.

In short, if you believe Aaron then his testimony - whilst not completely clearing my name, I admit - proves that at least one of the two remaining cylons at that time did not know my alignment, and chose not to kill me until they did. This makes the argument that I survived only because the cylons didn't want to kill one of their own, impossible. If Gaius and I were on the same team (the only possible way that he could know for certain I were mafia), then why did he visit me?