I'd honestly just like something in the same vein as the old ps1 games and before. I'd like an over world with a few optional towns and grinding points to explore with interesting main towns to explore as well. I'd like being able to talk to pretty much everyone and have random buildings to go into to discover random crap that could make every play through feel a little different. Ideally, not everyone would be voiced as this would make this more possible, but I doubt square would do that. I'd also like ATEs like in IX and a few side quests with a lot of personality as opposed to a bunch of marks and fetch quests.

I'd like some mini games like the golden saucer and triple triad that I could get into if I wanted. I'd also like a turn based game, but I could handle an action style in a similar style to the Tales games.

Basically, I want Square Enix to make a game like the games that made me fall in love with the series, but I doubt they will. I enjoy the newer games, but I don't feel the desire to keep going back to them like the older ones.