It really comes down who is voting. I feel Match 4 would have been a more even fight if the category was gameplay since that is SO2's strong point, but on the flip side, looking at the people who voted so far in that category, I think only two of them have actually played SO2, so even that wouldn't have saved it. That's kind of the issue here as well. A lot of "old school" titles that were nominated came from three people, and of those three, only one of them is actually voting.

My vote is going to be the tie breaker, so I'm abstaining for the most part, though I only see a handful of entries in the first round may end in a tie.