I disagree. Tidus didn't go psycho and try to destroy Spira in death. He watched over Yuna and lead her to safety in the Farplane.

Shuyin was so selfish in his love of Lenne that he didn't care who else died just as long as he got Lenne in the end.

Plus, Tidus is way cuter and has a sexier voice.
yep. my words exactly. plus, his clothes look way better, and Shuyin couldn't even come up with his own special moves. he had to bum his off of Tidus' overdrives. :P