Lets start off, its not cut throat is it really, I say what I like and what things probably need improving next time and the whole point of critque is its not definitive, its an opinion and I try to make it as detailed as possible to try and help as much as possible.

An evil (or cut throat) critque is when someone just posts all negative points and goes out of their way to be nasty, hummmm.

Anyway I won't respond any more to you, flame wars are not good on threads with peoples art on, it puts people off the subject which is the nice art they have produced.