Alright, I finally figured this out, and will post it for anyone else who might have this problem. AOL9.0 has a Pop-Up Blocker, but what I didn't know is that it also has a filter on it that blocks cookies from websites that have been blocked more than five times, and this site used to have pop-up ads. So I had to go to the spam filter and change some things and now life is good again. I hope this might help anyone else who has this problem.