Who would win...

[Ultima Shadow]

AND A BIG SWORD! You can't forget that

squall has a big sword too. clouds and squalls swords might be the same size so it is possible squall could win.

Seriously... since when did the one with the biggest sword have to win?
If it was for real, then Cloud wouldn't even be able to lift the sword... thus Squall would win. However... if it was a game battle, then it would depend on stats, weapons, items etc.

Seriously... having the biggest sword doesn't mean victory.

[aeris2001x2]

but Cloud is a strong guy who can wield heavy swords like they were Rapiers

[Ultima Shadow]

but Cloud is a strong guy who can wield heavy swords like they were Rapiers

Having the biggest sword still doesn't lead to victory.
But, Cloud is cooler and he (SPOILER)survived being impaled by Massamune... a sword that can kill a dragon in 2 hits. So maybe he would win... but I still refuse to vote.

[Lost Heretic]

Heres the battle...

Squall calls GF Bahaumet.
Cloud summons Bahaumet Zero.
Nothing happens as the two summons stare at eachother.
Both Bahaumets kill their summoners and go off to play cool games, like Final Fantasy 6 and Mechwarrior 2.

yay! I think I spelt Bahaumet wrong, too.

[Eminem]

if there was a hypno boob cloud would also be hypnotised.

[mr. anderson]

cloud would win,but he would have to make sure that squall didnt have his limit break because lionheart does 100,000+ so cloud would just enter the battle with his limit full and use omnislash to kill him

[Eminem]

squall would make sure he would get the limit break then he would cut cloud in to pieces

[Raistlin]

Cloud, because he's the slightly lesser wuss.

[Eminem]

hey squall is not a wuss. the wusses are cloud and you Railstin

[Master.Pug]

Squall would never hurt Cloud because he's erm.. ok, I won't finish that theory...

fact ist:

Squall sucks, Cloud wins

[Rand Al'Tor]

Ah, wonderfully useless FUN threads! (No really, I enjoy this)

Lessee: (SPOILER WARNING!)






Cloud's first years mark him as a failure SOLDIER and downgraded to regular army grunt. Not good. But after Niebelheim he HAS gotten some serious MAKO treatment which could have made him stronger and faster. Also, as a fighter he is able enough to get through a MAKO reactor.

Then there is Squall: He has passed. In fact, he is menioned to be a rathe rbrilliant stiudent. OTOH, unlike Cloud he is purely unmeddled human with only the GF's to boost him. (and GF's are countered by Materia)

So it'd be strength VS skill, with Cloud having the strength (and probably speed and stamina) of his mako enhancements, while Squall has ACTUALLY passed elite military training (as opposed to Cloud, who is just under the illusion that he passed them) Ipersonally think I'll have to go with Cloud on a one-on-one duel. If you ask me who would win in an actual war zone with people under his command, Squall takes the gold. A total antisocial ass he may be on occasions, but Squall has shown the ability to lead large number of troops, while Cloud relies on immediate violence with the occasional undercover mission.

[Polaris]

Squall duh!!!! But wasn't it great if both die!?

[Jolts]

Cloud and Squall are fighting, Squall starts to get the upper hand, Sephiroth gets pissed off at both of them and impales them both. Cloud wins, he's survived that before .

Seriously though, Cloud is pretty tough, he survived being in the Lifestream. However, Squall is also strong, as he survived travelling through time itself. I think the end would heavily revolve on pure luck. Both are good, and both use my favorite kind of weapon (sword), but Squall also uses the kind of weapon I disaprove of (gun). So, for that one reason, Cloud gets my vote. Otherwise, I wouldn't have voted.

[chu52]

Cloud and Squall are fighting, Squall starts to get the upper hand, Sephiroth gets pissed off at both of them and impales them both. Cloud wins, he's survived that before .

Seriously though, Cloud is pretty tough, he survived being in the Lifestream. However, Squall is also strong, as he survived travelling through time itself. I think the end would heavily revolve on pure luck. Both are good, and both use my favorite kind of weapon (sword), but Squall also uses the kind of weapon I disaprove of (gun). So, for that one reason, Cloud gets my vote. Otherwise, I wouldn't have voted.

The sprites from FF1 survived time travel, its not that hard to survivie, and they fought a man that they killed in the future whilst slipping the time stream.

[sephiroth_the_vile]

no one but squall and cloud is in this fight