I can't choose between three games.. The only three games I find scary is Silent Hill 1, Resident Evil 1 and Forbidden Siren. In three different ways. Silent Hill 1: psychological, and "I bet there's a monster in this room" kinda way, Resident Evil 1 for being the first survival horror game I played. I was 10, and scared. I don't really like Forbidden Siren. It's quite boring, but it's scary as hell. It always get me jumping when the screen flashes red and they're all after me. I hate the levels with snipers :/ I'll just not vote.