Style 1 - A tad distracting, it has that scanline effect on the navigation and the banner and seems cluttered.

Style 2 - Love it. Simple, sleek, effective and gets the point across. Granted Aeris <i>could</i> have been positioned a little lower to the point where we could at least fully see her face. This one's still getting my vote, though. It would take some adjusting to see EoFF as a grayish brownish site, though, so I would think it would be best to change the colours to fit the current EoFF.

Style 3 - I don't know about anyone else, but I just feel this one reeks with cliché design. Small text, all these minor pixel designs throughout, the hexagons, the bar code on the banner. The banner is also distracting and badly contrasts with the rest of the site.