Wha? Yuffie Has A Crush On Squall?

[Jack - Blademaster]

Whatever.What IS the fact?The heroes we are talking about are made up.They are not real.There are plenty of them in our minds.Some are evil because you think they are evil, others good as long as you think they are good.The power is in our imagination.We make them alive.
About storyline.There are a lot of untold things yet to be told.Let's wait for the KH II.Otherwise we are just wasting our time.
As for talking down to you, I'm sorry if my words offended you.Gods know,I didn't want it.I would chat more but it's time for sleep now.It's midnight in my country.It was very pleasant for me to talk with you.See ya!

[TheAbominatrix]

Fact can be substantiated by evidence, which is what I have provided. Fact can be proven.

I'm not saying we shouldnt imagine further, but if we speculate with any hope at coming up with a logical conclusion, the facts have to be taken into account. Yes, they are made up characters. But that doesnt mean their stories dont apply, it doesnt mean fact cant be taken into account. It'd be like, if at the end of VIII someone said Rinoa was really Squall's enemy. That's an opinion. But it can be disproven by fact. By many facts in fact.

All I'm saying is the characters, in the universe of KH, come from Hollow Bastion and Destiny Islands. In the universe of KH, the events of VIII didnt happen as they happened in the game, if they happened at all. We never learn how KH Squall gets his scar, so we can easily speculate about that. Perhaps Seifer existed in the world of Hollow Bastion, and gave Squall that scar. Perhaps in the world of HB, Cloud is Squall's rival, and Cloud gave him that scar. Maybe Rinoa exists in this universe at Hollow Bastion. Maybe she exists on a different world. Maybe she doesnt exist at all. There are no facts to prove one way or the other.

There are, however, facts to prove that Squall, Yuffie, Aerith, Cloud, and Cid all lived in Hollow Bastion, together. There are also facts that prove the events of VIII couldnt have happened. The world of VIII as we know it cannot exist as we know it... because of Selphie's age. Those are substantiated by fact.

[Lone Wolf Leonhart]

why can't he just live in hollow bastion, and originaly be from balamb?

[TheAbominatrix]

How did he get from Balamb to Hollow Bastion? Why would he go there? If he has his scar in KH and came from Balamb, then that means the events of VIII happened, which is impossible because of the Selphie factor. Aerith talks about living together, all of them, for quite some time.

Why cant he just be a character set in a different universe from the one we're used to, like Nomura said? Because...? Why?

Edit: Further proof exists in Tidus and Wakka. Tidus is (SPOILER)a dream in FFX. But nothing in the events of KH warrants him being there, much less warrants him staying. There are no fayths (at least that we know of) and no reason for Tidus to be there if he existed in the same universe as X.

Has anyone ever read Tsubasa? It's a Clamp manga that takes the main characters of a few different mangas (Card Captor Sakura and many others) and puts them in a whole different universe. It's a story with characters we know, but it exists apart from their normal stories. It's a very good example of the differences between KH and FF.

[Jack - Blademaster]

I just wanted to say that his story could take place as in FF VIII world just like ina another.Maybe in Hollow Bastion World.And you can't prove that his friends from the FF VIII world weren't with him there.Just like I can't prove they WAS there.We know too little about the game and universe in which heroes exist.So, it's just a matter of faith.Until the truth will be revealed.In the next Kingdom Hearts series games I suppose.

[TheAbominatrix]

I can, however, prove Selphie wasnt there, which is my entire point. The story as we know it did not happen. If a version of it happened in Hollow Bastion, we dont know, but we do know that it wouldnt be exactly the same.

You'll notice that I never said it wasnt possible that Rinoa existed, that Seifer gave him that scar, etc. Everything I did claim, however, is easily backed up by evidence and logic.