This one depends... if its a battle to get the lady, of course Irvine wins. He's too slick to let one get away. Edgar comes on too strong and Zidane's not really a ladies man, he just had time to win Garnet's approval.
If its a battle to the death, fighting, Edgar chainsaws his way through his adversaries.
Setzer vs. Cait Sith in a game of Backgammon.